Earnings season with tailwinds, but a high bar
The third-quarter reporting season has so far painted a mixed picture. Around a quarter of S&P 500 companies have reported to date, and 83% of them beat earnings expectations. At an average of just over 2%, however, positive surprises were much smaller than in the past. At the same time, expected earnings growth remains exceptionally strong at more than 29%, with a large share coming from companies that benefit from the AI investment cycle. As a result, critical voices are growing louder, as market breadth is as narrow as it was around the turn of the millennium and part of the reported earnings comes from book gains on stakes in unlisted AI companies. The key question is therefore whether the heavy investment can continue to be translated into rising revenues and margins.
Valuations depend heavily on earnings estimates
Valuations look much more moderate on the basis of expected earnings than on the basis of the past twelve months. The S&P 500 currently trades at around 26x trailing twelve-month earnings, but at around 21x and 18x on 2026 and 2027 earnings estimates, respectively. High earnings expectations have caused P/E ratios to decline for several months despite rising share prices. After the consolidation in September and October, valuations have in some cases fallen significantly again. In Europe, they are also much lower. Valuations thus depend crucially on whether earnings estimates can be achieved. For the main regions, however, the expected earnings paths appear plausible in principle. In individual segments, particularly semiconductors, the 2027 forward P/E of 15.7x compared with the current P/E of 37x implies earnings growth of around 135%. If these expected earnings fail to materialize, today’s seemingly low valuations will look considerably less attractive.
For context: the price-to-earnings ratio (P/E) compares a company’s share price with its earnings per share. The forward P/E uses expected earnings for the coming years instead of earnings over the past twelve months. If earnings expectations rise faster than share prices, the forward P/E falls even though the shares have become more expensive.